New England is known for lobster. Watch any movie, read any book, or check out influencers headed to Maine, New Hampshire, Massachusetts, and more, and you’ll see tantalizing photos of freshly made lobster rolls set against ocean views.
The Maine Menu is proud to offer a complete guide to the best lobster rolls you’ll find in the area, ranked by our good friend and collaborator @BostonLobsterRoll. All these recommendations originated from Boston Lobster Roll.
Prepare to plan your next vacation with the best seafood snacks you can imagine! Each lobster roll is ranked out of 10 points. You can assume this is a traditional roll if there is no detail about cold/hot styles or flavors. Here we go!
Editor’s Note: Seasonal means the lobster is only available during the warmer months, or the location is open for high tourism months. Always check the local website or Insta before heading to these mouthwatering destinations.
Ranked New England Lobster Rolls
Green Harbor Lobster Pound – 9.7
Freshly caught lobster with no-frills that deliver amazing natural flavors mixed with classic local ingredients and generous portions. A classic family-run seafood shack experience.
Marshfield, MA – Seasonal
Neptune Oyster – 9.7 (Hot Roll)
Neptune Oyster is a Boston institution. You want to order the hot buttered roll on a brioche bun for an intimate experience with sweet, tender lobster meat you’ll never forget.
Boston, MA – Year-round
Bite into Maine – 9.6
Our first Maine location, where lobster is a long-standing tradition, Bite into Maine provides local mayo and Connecticut-style butter. It is a food truck-turned-area favorite with waterfront views
Portland, ME – Seasonal
The Lobster Roller – 9.6
A perfect roadside destination, this shack offers balanced lobster rolls with fresh, lightly dressed meat on a traditional toasted split-top bun—simple preparation with complex taste.
South Kingstown, RI – Seasonal
Red’s Eats – 9.5
This is a legendary stop that has been featured in all kinds of magazines, famous TV shows, and reviewer blogs. You get a ton of lobster meat and chilled butter on the side with iconic Wiscasset views.
Wiscasset, ME – Seasonal
The Hourly Oyster House – 9.5
Visit Harvard Square and rub elbows with the elite while dining on a classic lobster roll in a stylish, yet somewhat surprisingly relaxed atmosphere focused on sustainable seafood.
Cambridge, MA – Year-round
Joe Fish Seafood Restaurant – 9.5
Hand-picked lobster dripping with butter is slammed into a fresh roll. You get a much more laid-back dining spot, which is why locals flock to Joe Fish’s every night.
North Andover, MA – Year-round
The Point – 9.4
Here, you’ll find coastal charms and casual elegance with a full bar and plenty of local music and events to enjoy while chowing down on a fresh lobster roll.
Marshfield, MA – Year-round
Woodman’s of Essex – 9.3
Founded in 1914, Woodman’s of Essex is famous for overstuffed rolls, locally sourced meat, and a perfectly balanced flavor. Be sure to order the fried clams, as this is another staple.
Essex, MA – Year-round
The Tack Room – 9.3
Getting farm-to-table ingredients is always a plus. The lobster rolls at The Tack Room are uniquely chef-driven, featuring an upscale design and premium flavors.
Lincoln, MA – Year-round
The Jolly Lobster – 9.2
Owned by the Chowder Factory, this food truck specializes in quarter-pound lobster rolls and classic lobster salad roll options. We love the rich chowders and homestyle mac & cheese as well.
Lowell, MA – Year-round
The Beach Plum – 9.2
Right on the coast – you’ll be treated to award-winning lobster rolls with jumbo-sized portions filling your belly before you dine on some homemade ice cream on a hot afternoon.
North Hampton, NH – Seasonal
Bob’s Clam Hut – 9.2
Started in 1956 in Kittery, Bob’s offers a simple lobster roll with flavors and ingredients in the vein of its unique roadside charm. It is a must-stop for many locals heading up north to the Maine coast.
Kittery, ME – Year-round
Footbridge Lobster – 9.2
Local fishermen sneak into this small dockside shack for lobster rolls straight from the ocean. It is right in the heart of Perkin’s Cove, with fantastic waterfront views.
Ogunquit, ME – Seasonal
Lincoln Tavern & Restaurant – 9.1
A stunning space that blends old school Americana with a rustic, wood-fired grill for endless delicious recipes. The menu if perfect for vegetarians, vegans, and gluten free diners, not to mention a thick and juicy roll for aficionados.
Boston, MA – Year-round
Mare Oyster Bar – 9.1
Here, lobster rolls meet upscale Italian flavors with a unique twist of Mediterranean influence. This is in the North End of Boston and fills up quickly on the weekends.
Boston, MA – Year-round
Local 02045 – 9.1
Right on the waterfront of Hull, you’ll find a no-fuss lobster roll that hits the spot when you’re trying to find a relaxing spot to take friends and family new to the area.
Hull, MA – Seasonal
Tony’s Clam Shop – 9.1
The trick to Tony’s is timing. This shop fills up quickly because it’s been around since 1964 and features sweeter lobster meat than you’ll usually find around Wollaston Beach.
Quincy, MA – Seasonal
James Hook & Co. – 9.1 for Hot, 8.7 for Cold
Since 1925, James Hook & Co. has remained a Boston staple, serving fresh lobster rolls shucked straight from its own seafood market and a family atmosphere that welcomes all ages.
Boston, MA – Year-round
Saltie Girl – 9.1
Don’t let the name fool you. Saltie Girl is upscale, offering a fresh lobster roll served hot or cold on a brioche bun in a stylish setting. It is a Back Bay gem and includes an extensive Raw Bar.
Boston, MA – Year-round
Bob Lobster – 9.1 for Surf & Turf, 8.8 for Thai Chili, 8.7 for Spicy, 8.4 for Truffle Roll, 8.2 for Cold, 8.1 for Fat Roll, 7.8 for Buffalo
Bob Lobster has a ton of options, all with their own unique and hearty twist. You’ll want to come back often to get a good idea of how the creative dishes and stunning marsh views change each season.
Newbury, MA – Seasonal
Lobster Claw – 9.1 for Hot, 8.9 for Cold, 8.5 for Mayo/Butter
The Lobster Claw is a classic spot in operation since 1976. It features a more minimalist menu, but overstuffed lobster rolls are always present. You should save room for the home-style chowder as well if you can.
North Reading, MA – Year-round
Pauli’s – 8.9
Another North End favorite with overpacked rolls and a fast-casual vibe. The restaurant has a strong reputation for larger serving sizes sure to satisfy any appetite.
Boston, MA – Year-round
Highroller Lobster Co. – 8.9 for Classic, 8.1 for Garlic Mayo, 7.7 for Jalapeno Mayo, 7.4 for Lobster Ghee
You’ll get a good variety of customizable options with your rolls, like lime mayo or curried ketchup. The classic is the best way to experience a Portland, ME lobster, but have fun and choose a few variations.
Portland, ME – Year-round
B & G Oysters – 8.9
This South End favorite is your go-to option if you love a sleek oyster bar. It has an intimate patio and premium seafood that cultivates the best Instagram photos.
Boston, MA – Year-round
Lobster Trap – 8.8
Ever since 1969, The Lobster Trap has thrilled guests with a Cape Cod experience. It’s great for both take-and-go as well as bigger parties or wholesale options if you want to host an event with lobster rolls on the menu. No visit to the White Mountains is complete without a stop at the Lobster Trap. This cozy, rustic shop features traditional seafood options, including thickly buttered lobsters straight from the water.
Bourne, MA – Year-round
Mission on the Bay – 8.8
Mission on the Bay is where to go to impress friends. The waterfront views are spectacular (especially on the rooftop deck) and you’ll get a large cocktail menu to accompany your roll.
Swampscott, MA – Year-round
Stephanie’s on Newbury – 8.7
Newbury is a well-traveled location in Boston’s Back Bay. Here you’ll find a bit more of an upscale atmosphere, but the perfect spot for stopping for a roll between shopping.
Boston, MA – Year-round
The Barking Crab – 8.7
We love the name! Plus, it doesn’t hurt you get a lively waterfront spot for lobster rolls loaded with sweet meat on a toasted bun as you watch the harborside activity all year long.
Boston, MA – Year-round
Salty’s Lobster Shack – 8.6
Salty’s has both a central location in Middleton and operates a food truck. You’ll have to track the food truck a bit on social media, but the upside is hot or cold rolls that are always from the freshest local working boats.
Middleton, MA and other various locations – Seasonal
Select Oyster Bar – 8.6
Oyster bars are fantastic locations for fresh lobster. Another Back Bay highlight, the curated wine selection, and upscale, chic design complement your meal perfectly.
Boston, MA – Year-round
Belle Isle Seafood – 8.6
There’s no better way to put this: Belle Isle is for the foodies. Overflowing lobster rolls with plenty of extra condiments and accessories, all set against unbeatable views of the Boston skyline.
Winthrop, MA – Year-round
Lobster Proper – 8.6 for Classic, 8.2 for Boom Sauce
Lobster Proper is exactly what you imagine. A minimalistic version of a roll focused more on fresh flavors than drowning in sauces. They can customize your preferred roll as the primary function of the business is catering and local community events. You’ll have to follow them on social media to find out where the crew is headed next.
Sharon, MA – Seasonal
Surfside – 8.6
Surfside is one of the best dining spots you can enjoy in the area. Underneath the blue toned umbrellas, you’ll be treated to fresh lobster rolls and custom cocktails while the ocean laps against the pier pillars below. There’s also a “surfcam” if you want to check on local conditions.
Salisbury, MA – Seasonal
Pink Door Catering – 8.5
Pink Door takes classic dishes and tosses in some exotic seasoning and flavors. They are a frequent option for local businesses hosting events, offering restaurant-quality seafood for all kinds of gatherings.
Portland, ME – Year-round
Legal Sea Foods – Harborside – 8.5
While tourists do flock to this Boston staple, you can usually find a table mid-day for a reliable, well-executed roll on a brioche bun set against a prime waterfront location.
Boston, MA – Year-round
John’s Footlong – 8.4
Cape Code is a well-known location for lobster rolls. This is a big P-Town destination with a no-frills roll you can count on to satisfy your cravings.
Provincetown, MA – Seasonal
Wicked Craft Co. – 8.4 for Asian Roll, 8.3 for Aioli, 8.2 for Cold
Wicked Craft Co. is a North End hot spot with thick lobster rolls and custom cocktails imprinted with red lipstick logos. They frequently host parties and can provide catering, so be sure to book as early as possible to try out their fantastic fare.
Boston, MA – Year-round
Roy Moore Lobster Co. – 8.4
This is another roadside shack turned local favorite offering fresh-picked meat straight from the tanks and a rustic waterfront setting you’ll love.
Rockport, MA – Seasonal
Falmouth Raw Bar – 8.4
Always order the oversized “Monstah Lobstah Roll,” and be sure to watch your raw bar selection carefully as the lively waterfront spot changes featured items all the time.
Falmouth, MA – Seasonal
Sesuit Harbor Café – 8.4
The trick to the Sesuit is the minimal filler. Not everyone wants an overstuffed roll, so you get a classic experience at a marina picnic table without feeling guilty for the mayo or butter.
Dennis, MA – Seasonal
Wicked Tasty Trucks – 8.3 for Hot, 8.1 for Cold
Another food truck you’ll need to track, you’ll find bold flavors piled high on a toasted bun that is usually part of local pop-up events and celebrations.
Massachusetts (various locations) – Seasonal
Atlantic Fish Co. – 8.3
The Atlantic Fish Co. is constantly featured in local dining guides and social media. It offers a more refined lobster roll and elegant seating for evening enjoyment.
Boston, MA – Year-round
Mikey’s Famous Roast Beef – 8.3
While Mikey’s is well known for roast beef, their take on a well-executed lobster roll hits just right during a hot afternoon or winter storm. It’s a good spot if you have a crew of friends that need a variety of dinner choices.
Billerica, MA – Year-round
Finz Seafood & Grill – 8.3
Better known as “HipFinz,” you can visit the local Witch Museum and then head over to this spot for a sustainably sourced lobster with innovative flavors.
Salem, MA – Year-round
Pat’s World Famous – 8.3
More of a casual surf spot, Pat’s offers good portions and creative twists when you want some flavor experimentation.
Ogunquit, ME – Seasonal
Moby Dick’s Restaurant – 8.3
You’ll feel like you’re in the water at Moby’s without the “wet.” The novel inspired restaurant is a seasonal favorite in Cape Cod with clambakes and even the occasional waiter who dresses up as a mascot. It’s family owned since 1983 with 1.5 and 2 pound lobsters available as well as Moby’s Jumbo Lobster Roll.
Wellfleet, MA – Seasonal
Tuscan Sea Grill & Bar – 8.3
Yup, another Italian menu that takes the classic New England roll and refines it a bit. You get an upscale feel to the space, but nothing that would require a suit and tie.
Newburyport, MA – Year-round
Rye Harbor Lobster Pound – 8.3
Always order the “Fluffy Chowder” as part of your lobster roll experience. This is a rich clam chowder topped with a lobster bisque.
Rye, NH – Seasonal
Fresh Catch Express – 8.3
Fast service and premium seafood are what you’ll get at Fresh Catch. The lobster is buttered and wrapped up in a toasted bun, so you can enjoy it wherever you’re heading next. Unfortunately, they have since shut down.
Gloucester, MA – Year-round
Victory Point – 8.2
Right in Marina Bay, you’ll get a Maine Lobster Roll at a Mass. beloved location. We prefer the brioche bun with lemon aioli and homestyle fries.
Quincy, MA – Year-round
George’s of Galilee – 8.2
Head over to an RI institution where locally sourced lobster is served across six dining rooms, an outdoor patio, and packed lines out the door in the summer months.
Narragansett, RI – Year-round
Lobstah on a Roll – 8.2
This is both a beloved Newbury Street location and a satellite Florida mainstay. There are minimal fillers, but bolder flavors that border on classic and make sense for southern diners.
Boston, MA – Year-round
Kelly’s Roast Beef – 8.2
Another roast beef purveyor that serves a solid lobster roll, lightly dressed, and on a classic toasted bun. It’s more of a fast-casual spot on the North Shore when you need a quick bite.
Multiple Locations, MA – Year-round
The Nautilus – 8.1
Get a creative twist on lobster rolls from a globally inspired menu deep in Seaport. It is a great experience for those wanting a “fresh” flavor.
Boston, MA – Year-round
Yankee Lobster – 8.1 for Classic, 7.7 for Fenway
Here you’ll find a family-run market and restaurant with classic rolls and quick access to plenty of preferred New England merch for souvenirs.
Boston, MA – Year-round
Lookout Farm – 8.1
Be sure to order the craft cider and visit when orchids are in bloom. The natural beauty of this spot is perfect for those who love a scenic farm with a relaxed lobster roll.
Natick, MA – Seasonal
Wicked Lobsta – 8.1 for Hot, 7.8 for Cold
Yes, the busy Faneuil Hall Marketplace has some good lobster rolls. You’ll have to fight your way through the tourists, but there is always the Lobsta Mac & Cheese if you’re in a spicy mood.
Boston, MA – Year-round
Hopothecary Ales – 8.1
Take your time to browse the expansive craft beer selection before chowing down on a rich lobster roll served seasonally in the laid-back taproom.
North Reading, MA – Year-round
Fresco’s Malden – 8.1
Here is a Mediterranean spot that ensures everyone in your party gets a fantastic meal while you fill up on seasonally served lobster rolls with a lot of custom sauces.
Malden, MA – Year-round
Poppy’s Raw Bar – 7.9
Poppy’s is the way to go if you prefer an upscale raw bar with a modern twist. All the food, including the fresh rolls, includes a stylish take on classic New England fare.
Mashpee, MA – Seasonal
Little Harbor Lobster Company – 7.9
Marblehead is an amateur historian’s wet dream. This family and the fisherman-owned market provides award-winning lobster rolls for an authentic boat-to-table meal.
Marblehead, MA – Year-round
The Squealing Pig – 7.9
Another P-Town favorite, The Squealing Pig offers a lobster roll featuring fresh lobster meat served on a brioche roll with bacon, all with a friendly atmosphere and local gossip.
Provincetown, MA – Year-round
Sullivan’s Castle Island – 7.9
Serving satisfying rolls since 1952, you get a fresh ocean breeze with classic food flavors you can always count on before going for a stroll on the waterfront.
Boston, MA – Seasonal
North End Fish & Sushi – 7.9
Lobster rolls? At a sushi spot? Yup! Here you’ll find a fusion of Japanese food with New England flavors, including a combo option perfect for your heftier appetites.
Boston, MA – Year-round
Red’s Best – 7.9
Head inside the Boston Public Market for a classic lobster roll where your cash goes to help support local New England fishermen through improved traceability and sustainability.
Boston, MA – Year-round
The Clam Box – 7.8
Directly across from Wollaston Beach, the Clam Box has provided amazing rolls since 1968 with plenty of variety and welcome ocean views.
Quincy, MA – Year-round
The Red House – 7.8
Dine on thick lobster meat in a historic 19th-century home right in the middle of Harvard Square. Be sure to try the lobster risotto or lobster carbonara!
Cambridge, MA – Year-round
Cousins Maine Lobster – 7.8
Cousins is a nationally ranked food truck chain with fixed locations all over New England. They feature Maine-style lobster rolls with plenty of sauce varieties.
Various Locations – Year-round
Woods Hill Pier 4 – 7.8
The lobster popover is the real treat. It features crème fraiche, celery, and red onion in a homemade warm popover and Old Bay chips, a welcome twist on the traditional roll.
Boston, MA – Year-round
Joe’s On A Roll – 7.8
Another family-run seafood staple with a diverse selection of lobster rolls committed to fresh, locally sourced meats.
Beverly, MA – Year-round
Union Oyster House – 7.7
Created in 1826, the Union Oyster House is the oldest continuously operated restaurant in the heart of Boston. The chilled lobster is the best, but you cannot miss the coleslaw.
Boston, MA – Year-round
The Beachcomber – 7.7
Right along the dunes of Cahoon Hollow Beach, you’ll find fresh lobster served in hot, cold, and seasonal styles. However, the price may be a bit more than you’re used to paying.
Wellfleet, MA – Seasonal
The Porthole Restaurant & Pub – 7.7
Back in Maine, this time at the historic Custom House Wharf, where you’ll get 5oz of locally sourced lobster meat with either lemon aioli or butter – all on Portland’s largest waterfront deck.
Portland, ME – Year-round
Salty’s at Second Beach – 7.7
What used to be Easton’s Beach Snack Bar has relocated to a much better dining area best known for the Twin Lobster Rolls order with friends.
Middletown, RI – Seasonal
Longboards Restaurant & Bar – 7.7
More of a hotspot for flatbread pizza enthusiasts, the neighborhood joint is a good seasonal solution for lobster rolls in an active bar setting.
Salem, MA – Year-round
Lifted Rooftop Restaurant & Bar – 7.6
You’ll have to ride the lift all the way to the fifth floor of the Omni Boston Hotel at Seaport for this contemporary dining experience where curated cocktails meet New England flavors.
Boston, MA – Year-round
Bennett’s Sandwich Shop – 7.6
Hope you’re in the mood for meat! This award-winning lobster roll features over a quarter pound of fresh Maine lobster on a gourmet roll across multiple locations.
Multiple Locations – Year-round
The Lexington – 7.6
Right at Cambridge Crossing is one of the few local roof decks perfect for an after-work lobster roll with your friends in a greenhouse-designed space with views of The Common.
Cambridge, MA – Year-round
Steamers – 7.6
The problem with Steamers is that you may mistake it for only a market. They also have an eatery with locally sourced dishes, including a popular lobster roll sandwich.
Newton, MA – Year-round
Turner’s Seafood Grill & Market – 7.5
Turner’s is more of a traditional pubhouse. You can see the influence in all the dishes like Oysters Rockefeller, Lobster Pie, Baked Stuffed Shrimp, and lobster rolls.
Melrose, MA – Year-round
The White Bull Tavern – 7.4
The White Bull is where you go after a show or a long day of touring the city. It is a cozy stop with a decent patio and skillet-cooked appetizers or pizza for those in your party who don’t understand the delight of lobster rolls.
Boston, MA – Year-round
Luke’s Lobster – 7.4
Founded by a 3rd generation lobsterman, Luke’s features sustainably sourced meat with a quarter-pound roll atop a buttered split top bun and secret spices drizzled for a rich finish.
Multiple Locations – Year-round
Chart House – 7.4
Walk along the historic Long Wharf, and you’ll find the slightly higher-priced Maine lobster salad roll of the Chart House. While the food is excellent, you’re also paying for the ambiance.
Boston, MA – Year-round
The Canteen – 7.4
The Canteen is a well-known P-Town location with a casual, eatery styled décor featuring hand-shucked lobster rolls and crispy Brussels sprouts.
Provincetown, MA – Year-round
Boston Sail Loft – 7.4
Whoever owns this location knew what they were doing! The food is great, and you’ll get a classic lobster roll with harbor views that would make any influencer jealous.
Boston, MA – Year-round
Boston Chowda Co. – 7.4
Back to Faneuil Hall, the Chowda Co. provides fresh Maine lobster rolls alongside pot pies, wraps, salads, and soups.
Boston, MA – Year-round
Lobster Tail Seafood – 7.4
The lobster rolls here are a signature dish, but be sure to explore the rest of the dine-in/take-out menu if you’re in the area for a while. This is a good “return to” location.
North Andover, MA – Year-round
Clam Shack Salem – 7.4
Plenty of spaces around Salem are too touristy. The Clam Shack gives you a decent break with reasonable prices and convenient seating that anyone can enjoy.
Salem, MA – Year-round
Tempo – 7.3
Tempo is a part of Waltham’s “Restaurant Row.” It only serves lobster rolls occasionally compared to the rest of the bar menu, but the vibrant atmosphere is a must-visit.
Waltham, MA – Year-round
The Bancroft – 7.3
The Bancroft is best described as a modern American steakhouse, but it does serve a fresh Maine Lobster roll on a toasted brioche bun with homemade chips.
Burlington, MA – Year-round
The Big E – 7.3 for RI Building, 6.9 for Maine House, 5.9 for MA House
The Big E is a recreation space and festival center. Spread out in the space are different buildings themed to surrounding states featuring incredible food like hot, cold, and spicy lobster rolls.
West Springfield, MA – Seasonal
Tony C’s Sports Bar & Grill – Seaport – 7.2
Return to Boston’s Seaport and get the classic “bar” scene well-known in Bean Town. It’s a great space for a classic lobster roll and watching the game with friends.
Boston, MA – Year-round
Lucky Finn Cafe – Scituate – 7.2
In Scituate Harbor, you’ll find a cozy little dining space with a diverse menu, including the “Kickstarter” breakfast sandwich and seasonal lobster rolls.
Scituate, MA – Year-round
Scholars American Bistro & Cocktail Lounge – 7.1
Right along the Freedom Trail is a stylish and vibrant lounge perfect for networking and enjoying tasty cocktails, refreshing beers, and mouthwatering lobster rolls.
Boston, MA – Year-round
The Cod Squad Food Truck – 7.1
This is a food truck owned and operated by Captain Marden’s Seafood. You’ll get award-winning seafood, including the signature lobster roll.
Wellesley, MA – Year-round
Seamark Seafood & Cocktails – 6.9
James Beard award-winning chef Michael Schlow heads the menu with refined seafood and a fresh lobster roll before heading into the hidden speakeasy in the same space – Old Wives’ Tale.
Everett, MA – Year-round
Wegmans Market Café – Burlington – 6.9
Wegmans is a well-known marketplace with locations throughout New England, but the Burlington spot features a wonderful lobster roll and casual dining spot for a quick lunch.
Burlington, MA – Year-round
Batson River Brewing & Distilling – Kennebunk – 6.9
Distilling and brewery companies make great food! Here you get a full menu of pub fare, including a fresh lobster roll you can enjoy on the dog-friendly patio.
Kennebunk, ME – Year-round
Shuckers World Famous Raw Bar – 6.8
On the waterfront at Woods Hole, you’ll get casual dining and fun harbor views while savoring fresh seafood dishes, including lobster rolls, chowder, and a raw bar.
Woods Hole, MA – Seasonal
Cusser’s Roast Beef & Seafood – 6.7
Cusser’s is a long-standing North Shore space with a signature “Three Way” roast beef sandwich and house-made sauces that complement lobster roll diners.
Boston, MA – Year-round
Warren Tavern – 6.6
Founded in 1780, Warren’s offers lobster rolls and shepherd pie where American greats like George Washington and Paul Revere once sat.
Charlestown, MA – Year-round
Courthouse Seafood – 6.6
For more of a family-run experience, head to East Cambridge and dine on fresh lobster rolls from the adjacent fish market and community-built atmosphere.
Cambridge, MA – Year-round
The Lobster Stop – 6.6
This is a must if you live in a 3-mile radius of the Lobster Stop. You want to include it in your weekly rotation due to the winter delivery, saving you a lot of hassle when you have a lobster craving.
Quincy, MA – Year-round
State Street Provisions – 6.5
Another Long Wharf staple, you’ll find contemporary dining in a rustic setting with a lobster roll served with chives on brioche.
Boston, MA – Year-round
The Emerald Rose – 6.4
Get a mix of traditional Irish classics and hearty pub fare featuring dishes like a lobster roll at a slightly higher price tag in either Maine or Connecticut style.
Billerica, MA – Year-round
Reelhouse Marina Bay – 6.4 for hot, 6.2 for cold
Enjoy nautical-themed dining with either hot or cold lobster rolls served alongside mixed greens and chips.
Quincy, MA – Seasonal
The Raw Bar at Island Creek Oyster Farm – 6.3
This Duxbury Bay raw bar features freshly harvested oysters and seafood alongside a casual indoor/outdoor dining space with local craft beer.
Duxbury, MA – Year-round
Papa Gino’s – 6.1
Anyone who grew up in New England knows Papa Gino’s. It is our area’s version of a pizza joint that will occasionally serve local favorites, including lobster rolls.
Multiple Locations – Seasonal
Bentley’s Roast Beef – 6.1
Bentley’s provides a stomach-filling thick roll sourced from Cape Ann that is seasoned with your customized selection of sauces and sides.
Amherst, NH – Seasonal
Burtons Grill & Bar – 6.1
If you prefer a modern American cuisine experience, you can enjoy a fresh lobster roll with French fries and coleslaw served chilled or hot. There are gluten-free options as well. There are many locations around CT, FL, and MA. We visited the Burlington stop.
Burlington, MA – Year-round
Surf Restaurant – Portsmouth – 5.8
We wish this was higher up on the list because the menu and atmosphere are entertaining. While the lobster roll is good, they just need a few tweaks to jump the ranks.
Portsmouth, NH – Year-round
Row 34 – 5.8
Inside Boston’s Fort Point is Row 34. The restaurant features a good craft beer selection and an extensive raw bar with a warm “Ethel’s Creamy Lobster” roll or a cold version.
Boston, MA – Year-round
Pinehurst Tavern – 5.6
Our final location in Billerica is a local sports bar with live entertainment and a seasonal lobster roll aligned with good pub fare.
Billerica, MA – Year-round
Notes from Boston Lobster Roll
What always makes a great roll, in my opinion, is the lobster meat. When it’s fresh-as-can-be, it makes a world of difference in the texture and taste. Frozen meat can be a little rubbery, while fresh meat is more tender.
Another important aspect is the bun. The traditional split top hotdog bun is what many are used to. More and more places are using a brioche bun though. It holds up better with larger rolls, and its buttery sweetness pairs well with lobster. Having the bun buttered and toasted is always a good thing.
For cold rolls, or “Maine-style”, the amount of mayonnaise is the key. When there’s too much, it takes away from the flavor and texture of the meat.
Many spots mix in greens with their cold roll — celery, chives, bed of lettuce, or shredded lettuce. Occasionally, you’ll even get a roll with two greens. I’m not a fan of too many greens, too much crunch.
When it comes to hot rolls, or “Connecticut-style”, butter served on the side is crucial. I have found that if the butter is poured on for you, by the time it gets to your table, the butter soaks into the bun. This can make the bun soggy, and cause the roll to fall apart.
Besides the lobster meat itself, I think less is more with a great roll.
Final Thoughts
That covers all the great locations for delicious lobster rolls you could want in the New England area. If you know of a destination we didn’t get to, please be sure to leave a comment so we can add it to our future list.
Thanks again to Boston Lobster Roll for their fantastic ranking. You can follow them on Instagram @bostonlobsterroll and check out the latest videos, photos, and reviews of local favorites.
Here’s to a great season of lobster!